Food tips • holidays • recipes

Mouthwatering turkey recipe for Christmas and Thanksgiving

Written by Christian Ebersol
4 Minute Read
Published on Dec 05, 2023

If you enjoyed our Turkey this Thanksgiving or perhaps you missed it and are still salivating for one, we have good news! There are still 99 left and if you use the code TURKEYXMAS by December 17th you can receive an additional 10% off. 

This recipe is courtesy of the one and only Ruth Flaherty, a 99 Counties customer in the Chicago area. 

Time to defrost: The size of your bird  determines how long you need to defrost. A guideline: 24 hours for each 5 pounds:

  • 10-12 lb. 2 days
  • 12-14 lb. 2 ½ days
  • 14-16 lb. 3 days
  • 16-18 lb. 3 ½ - 4 days

    Brine: A brine is optional, but provides so much flavor. 24 hours before cooking day. Ingredients: 

    • 2 Cups water 
    • 1 Cup sea salt
    • 10 garlic cloves
    • 10 bay leaves
    • 1 Tablespoon whole black peppercorns
    • Additional One Gallon of water (enough water to completely submerge turkey) 

      Combine first 5 ingredients in a saucepan and bring to boil, make sure salt is dissolved and let it cool completely before adding to brine bag / raw turkey. 

      Place the turkey in a brine bag on a cookie sheet and add mixture from saucepan and enough water to fully submerged the bird. Make sure most all the air is out of the bag and refrigerate breast side down until cooking day. Brine at least 8 hours for up to 48 hours for best results.

      Compound Butter 

      • 1 stick unsalted - room temperature
      • 5 garlic cloves - minced 
      • 1 teaspoon sea salt
      • 1 whole package of fresh thyme - leaves picked of stems
      • 1 Tablespoon tomato paste
      • 2 Teaspoons maple sugar

        In a bowl combine all ingredients- soft butter, salt, minced garlic, leaves of thyme, tomato paste, and maple sugar.

        Mix together until fully incorporated. Set aside until step 5 during Cooking Day.

        Additional ingredients for Turkey:

        • large tomato 
        • 1 more package of fresh thyme (with stems) for turkey cavity
        • 1 teaspoon apple cider vinegar for pan sauce
        • ½ cup white cooking wine

          Cooking Day:

          1. Make compound butter (ingredients above)
          2. First, preheat the oven at 500 degrees.
          3. Remove bird from packaging (or brine) and rinse inside and out with cold water. Discard the brine. 
          4. Place the bird on a roasting rack inside a roasting pan and pat dry with paper towels. 
          5. Apply butter inside the cavity and under the skin of the whole bird. Place the whole tomato and more fresh thyme into the turkey's cavity. Tuck the wings underneath the bird and coat the skin liberally with compound butter.  If your oven has a probe thermometer this is the perfect time to use it. IInsert the thermometer into the thickest portion of the turkey breast. Make sure the thermometer does not touch bone, gristle or the pan.  Set the thermometer alarm to 161 degrees F. (if available)
          6. Cook the bird for 30 min at 500 degrees 
          7. After 30 minutes,  turn the oven down to 350 degrees ​.  If the breast got dark in these 30 min you can cover it with foil to keep the bird from getting too dark. A 14 to 16 pound bird should require a total of 2 to 2 1/2 hours of roasting.  After 2 ½ hours remove from the oven and make sure to check the temperature turkey legs, breast and wings are at/above 165 degrees F. 
          8. Let the turkey rest, loosely covered with foil 15 minutes before carving. 

            Pan Sauce: All the butter and turkey juices in the roasting pan will make a delicious sauce. 

            1. Carefully (the roasting pan will be hot) pour juices into the saucepan and simmer with 1 teaspoon of apple cider vinegar and ½ c white wine for 10 minutes.
            2. Strain through a fine mesh strainer to remove any thyme leaves or other bits from the pan, and serve with turkey. 
              Older Post Newer Post

              Meat the way it’s meant to be

              Sign up for exclusive deals, juicy recipes, farmer stories & more.
              Missing required field

              By signing up, you agree to receive marketing emails from 99 Counties at the email address provided. We respect your privacy.